menu
Insights

Valuable insights of the auto
industry and service drives.

Data
Expectations
Social Media
Strategies
Targeting
Service Business

Customer Feedback Shaping Service Departments

Fixed Ops Revenue Streams Beyond Maintenance

Transparency: The Key to Winning Fixed Ops Customers in 2025

Mastering Dealership Service Customer Conversations

Navigating Fixed Ops Challenges: Insights from Ron Blum at NADA Show 2025

Service Department Revenue: Slow Months

Technicians’ Impact on Dealership Retention: The Secret to Long-Term Success

The Fixed Ops Assassin Strikes Again: Joe Sassin on Transforming Service Departments

The Impact of Rising Interest Rates on Service Retention

From Boss to Coach: Transforming Fixed Ops Management with People-First Leadership

From Boss to Coach: Transforming Fixed Ops Management with People-First Leadership

The traditional management approach in fixed operations was a top-down structure for years: “Do as I say.” But today’s most effective fixed ops leaders are rewriting the playbook. They’re trading in the title of “boss” for something far more impactful: coach.

This shift toward people-first leadership is more than a trend. It’s a strategic transformation that boosts morale, deepens trust, improves technician and advisor retention, and directly impacts bottom-line performance.

Let’s explore what this transformation looks like—and how you can lead it.

Transforming Fixed Ops Management

The Problem with “Old-School” Fixed Ops Management

Fixed ops departments have long been driven by performance metrics: hours per RO, CSI scores, and effective labor rate. While these numbers still matter, the way to achieve them is changing.

Old-school management styles—command-and-control, fear-based motivation, and reactive discipline—may get short-term results, but over time, they lead to burnout, low engagement, and costly turnover.

According to Gallup, fewer than one in four U.S. employees strongly trust their organization’s leadership. In fixed ops, where skilled technicians and advisors are in high demand, trust isn’t a luxury. It’s a necessity.

Coaching Is the New Leadership

What’s the difference between a boss and a coach?

A BossA Coach
Gives OrdersGives Feedback
Demands ResultsDevelops People
Assumes ControlBuilds Trust

Today’s most successful fixed ops leaders are shifting from micromanagement to mentorship. They’re walking the shop, listening to their teams, addressing roadblocks, and creating environments where employees feel heard, valued, and supported.

Leadership expert Dr. Brené Brown puts it this way:

“Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.”
Dare to Lead by Brené Brown

Coaching leadership means having direct, honest conversations, not just when someone is underperforming but also when they’re succeeding. It means providing feedback that fuels growth, not fear.Think of it like the MPI service advisors should be presenting to clients. A best practice is to always present the green items. Letting a client know which components of their vehicle are in good working order build trust. Offering affirming feedback to an employee for the aspects of their job they are performing well does the same. 

Build Trust. Boost Retention.

In a service department, trust isn’t built in one meeting. It’s earned over time through consistent, empathetic leadership.

Simon Sinek, renowned leadership author, explains:

“Leadership is not about being in charge. It is about taking care of those in your charge.”
Leaders Eat Last by Simon Sinek

When your advisors and techs know you care about them as people, not just producers, they’re more likely to stay. And in today’s technician shortage, retention is a competitive advantage.

According to a 2017 Cox Automotive report, employee turnover remains one of the most expensive problems facing dealerships, especially in service. Replacing a single technician can cost thousands in recruiting, onboarding, and lost productivity.

Coaching Improves Performance

Some leaders worry that a people-first approach will lead to lower accountability. In reality, the opposite is true.

Google’s massive leadership study, Project Oxygen, found that the most effective managers are:

  • Good coaches
  • Empowering, not micromanaging
  • Invested in team members’ success and well-being

A technician who feels valued is more likely to go the extra mile. An advisor who feels supported is more confident in upselling services. A team that trusts its leader doesn’t just meet expectations—it exceeds them.

How to Make the Shift From Boss to Coach

Ready to transform your fixed ops leadership style? Here are a few action steps:

1. Start with One-on-Ones

Regular, structured check-ins with each team member allow you to listen, give feedback, and set goals collaboratively.

2. Ask More Questions

Coaches don’t give all the answers. They ask the right questions to help people think critically and solve problems independently.

3. Celebrate Wins (Big and Small)

Recognition is fuel for motivation. Highlighting progress—not just perfection—builds morale and momentum.

4. Invest in Development

Provide training. Offer mentorship. Encourage certifications. When people see a future with you, they stick around.

5. Model the Culture You Want

Your team mirrors your mindset. If you lead with humility, empathy, and accountability, they’ll do the same.

Final Thoughts

The service department isn’t just about cars—it’s about people. Your leadership style sets the tone for how your team performs, grows, and stays. By becoming a coach instead of a boss, you’ll do more than hit numbers—you’ll create a culture of trust, excellence, and loyalty that drives long-term success.

For more fixed ops insights, visit TVI Market

Let's get moving. Get your customized marketing plan today.

Thank You! A representative will reach out to you shortly!
Next
Captcha
Submit

View All

Follow Us

© 2025 TVI-MarketPro3 | Privacy Policy

Sign up for email updates